View Single Post
Old 03-25-2010, 02:10 PM   #6
Tony Black
Member Tony Black is offline
Tony Black's Avatar
Join Date: May 2009
Location: Carlisle  England
Posts: 379
Re: Style Suited For Army Infantry?

Generally speaking Boxing, Muay thai, Judo , BJJ and wrestling are thought of as styles which have greatest carryover into sport fighting. And they do give alot of carry over into Self Defense... The comonality between those styles is your often sparring against live reacting unpredictable opponents. As opposed to where most Traditional Martial arts (TMA's) fail - where most of the stuff is drilled against air or against opponents attacking with predictable set piece moves who pause politely as you dispatch them....

Originally Posted by Kevin Piercy View Post
Thanks guys.

I'm going to do Army Combatives as part of my training I'm just thinking of things outside of that

Kevin then id look to strike based training.

Boxing would be a first choice from which id adapt the strikes when outside the ring. ie use a palm heel instead of fist for head shots. For your purposes and considering your time limited id look for developing a powerful right cross.

Muay Thai would also be good and fun. Id emphasize right cross, elbows and low round kicks.

If you want to have a quick dirty Self defense application id look to "index" with my lead hand (ie left) and then repeatedly apply right cross palm heel (the best primary tool) to the oppositions head (the best target)....

By indexing i mean tie up, lightly touch or remove any obstructions and obstacles to your primary tool. A obstacle might be his lead hand guard. Example grasp it push it into his chest. Or merely pull it down... Then repeatedly strike using explosive impactive tools to create brain shake and neutralise your opponent.

As a basic tactic ive found this extremely effective and it can be drilled well on pads.

Judo fun and a extremely good conditioning session - the better SD carry over IMHO comes from the standing grappling and the ability to remain on your feet with a opponent trying to take you down.... Positional groundwork is great BUT any system for SD which emphasis going to ground as a valid tactic is lunacy IMHO. But any good fighter should learn groundwork - if only so that they can regain there feet faster.

I feel the US army combative course fails in this regard as most of what ive read points to a huge groundwork bias. Theres still seems to be alot of useful stuff in there. But that inbuilt ground emphasis is plain wrong imho.

Going to ground (some of this applies to even standing grappling) should be a big no-no because it ties you up and commits you to ONE individual. Often negates any chance of reacting to another attack (a 12 year old kid could kick your head off quite easily). Its espically nasty if your opposition manages to draw a edged weapon... Also with regards to larger size, strength and power disparities grappling becomes alot more dicey. There are no weight categories on the street or battlefield.

If i was facing some monster 2 (or more!) times my bodyweight grappling still wouldnt be my first choice. Effective striking would be. My chances my still be slim - but they dont become greater choosing grappling out of desperation.

And regarding the battlefield - huge amounts of techniques immediately become impractical whilst wearing bodyarmour and webbing carrying a weapon etc. Let alone the enviroment such as shattered glass/fragmenation on the ground. If some1 pulls guard in a truely life or death situation whats stopping you from deadlifting them and dropping there back onto a curb or similar object? What works well in a sporting arena often doesnt translate well into a SD arena.

Learn groundwork absoutely this stuff can happen despite your best efforts! But dont make it your primary choice for hand to hand.

Good luck with it Kevin!

Originally Posted by Jamie J. Skibicki View Post
Also, when someone is tied up, it's harder to run away, get help and what not.

You shouldnt be beating on people who are tied up Jaime!
The live drill is violent, it's sudden and chaotic, it's over before you've even got started and you're never prepared for what happens....welcome to fighting - Mick Coup

Last edited by Tony Black; 03-25-2010 at 02:20 PM..
  Reply With Quote