|05-20-2005, 03:10 AM||#31|
Looks to me like:
6:00 to 8:00 minutes is an average range for regular, well conditioned, CrossFitters.
5:00 to 6:00 is where your typical Pro MMA fighter resides.
I disagree, you have one result in the 6-8 min range (me) and two in the 5-6min range (Adrian and Rutman's son), and the best time the MMA guys got was 5:50, only just in that zone (how many in the 6-8?)...I reckon there are quite a few CrossFitters who can hit the 5-6 range too, based on my WOD performance relative to others.
4 out of the 6 CrossFitters who posted (not fair to include Steve Cotter), posted times faster than the 5:50 which is the best the MMA guys got. That puts me and Jay at somewhere below average, and the average CrossFitter being fitter than a typical pro MMA guy. You can't disregard results because they're too good.:happy:
|05-20-2005, 07:05 AM||#36|
You made an interesting point regarding your UGLY cleans. This has been my observation over the last two years. Glassman explains this as an expected outcome of the challenge.
For this workout I know my pc turned sour on rounds 4 and 5 as well. I also watched this with the rest of my class that evening. Some folks pulled from a straighter leg position. I also had to coach them at the rack position. Some of my athletes wanted to turn this around too quickly. I ask them to pause so they actually racked it.
From my view, someone could be less sound technically but ‘strong like bull’ and muscle through this workout.
|05-20-2005, 08:26 AM||#37|
I'm an idiot! I just finished this using 85# doing 5 rounds of power clean AND JERKS setted with 15 pushups....9:37.
I'll try this one again in a week, this time doing the correct workout. Oh well, it's good practice for Grace.....
|05-20-2005, 04:50 PM||#40|
Here's what I'm seeing...
Rutman 5:29 (Rutman's son)
Meeks 6:50 (my buddy who turned me on to CrossFit but didnt post here)
Owen 7:00 + (thats me. never broken 7 minutes)
Pro MMA guys... pretty much all under 6:30, now have some in the low 5's (5:17) but still none to break 5 minutes.
I dont see Rutman and Atkins as "average" CrossFitter's. And I suspect when a challenge like this is thrown out that the higher end folks are probably more likely to respond to it in general.
I bet if all the CrossFitter's did this test, times would climb a bit versus the median that we see from this small sample.
I suspect the average CrossFitter is in the 6:00 to 8:00 minute range, although I agree that these scores alone don't show that. I'm extrapolating a bit.
I also think it's clear that the elite from CrossFit (or at least the high end) are clearly ahead of the elite fighters from the MMA pool.
My original hypothesis appears to be correct, in that Professional MMA fighters, with corporate sponsors that pay them to "train" for a living to become "brutally fit", can be out-paced on a brutal fitness test by non-professional athletes (regular guys) who are training in the CrossFit method.
I'd say that's a result that should raise some eyebrows!
|Thread||Thread Starter||Forum||Replies||Last Post|
|Pro's vs. Joe's with Randy Coture Th. 1/25/07||John Seiler||CrossPit||4||01-27-2007 10:07 AM|
|Renzo & Millitech on 60 Minutes||Keith Wittenstein||CrossPit||13||12-30-2006 11:02 PM|
|CV Exercise over 30 minutes=Bad||Charlie Reid||Fitness||14||08-27-2006 08:45 AM|
|WOD time goal of 20 minutes?||James Napier||Workout of the Day||1||08-06-2006 07:14 PM|
|Cut 10 minutes Off Triathlon||Jon Pappas||Testimonials||3||07-28-2003 08:25 PM|